A Beginning Is A Very Delicate Time

“very obvious things are often overlooked.”[1] –Alan Watts

 

Dune is a beloved franchise, a classic of science fiction that likely will be studied and discussed well into the future.[2] By the time the third novel, Children of Dune, was published in 1976, it had become a run-away best seller. Ryan Britt declares that with the third novel, “None of this was niche. All of it was mainstream.”[3] Perhaps one day my sons will be able to purchase the 100th anniversary edition. But this essay is not necessarily about Dune’s longevity, though that is an important aspect. Rather, this essay is about a set of themes within the series that almost no one seems to have discussed, at least within the academic sphere: namely, the deeply Orientalist framing of the Dune novels themselves and the ways in which Dune has helped to perpetuate Orientalist imagery.

Dune as a fiction series is deeply steeped in Orientalist imagery. Such is the extent of this Orientalist imagery and the novel’s success that Dune has acted as a transmission vector for the continued propagation of Orientalism. Oriental imagery helped to sell the book as a science fiction epic, especially its sense of verisimilitude and its sense of “alien”-ness. Dune helps us to see the ways in which Oriental images have been core to the Western story-telling experience but also gives us an avenue to see how these ideas keep themselves alive, even by those who would otherwise be opposed to such imagery (i.e. its own author and its intended and inherited audience). Rana Kabbani, in her book Imperial Fictions: Europe’s Myths of Orient, wonders openly why and how it is that Orientalism continues to exist in a post-colonial world: “how can Orientalism still dare show its face?”[4] She is not alone, for decades this has been a driving academic question as well as a source of frustration for historians as the old themes, once thought dead, continue to rear their ugly heads. The Dune series gives us a glimpse of the answer as to why they keep returning. 

With the thesis clearly stated, before proceeding further there are a few caveats with this essay. Firstly, this essay assumes that the reader either has read Dune or at the very least has a passing familiarity with the content. As such, details of the plot will be discussed at length, if any reader is concerned about spoilers, I do not recommend that they read this essay until they have finished reading the novels for themselves. Secondly, while the primary focus of this analysis are the six Dune novels that Frank Herbert himself wrote there will be occasional diversions to not only other writings Frank Herbert produced but details of his personal life as well. Connectedly, there will be occasional divergences in examining a few of the adaptations of the novels, particularly the films. Similarly, while this essay is primarily a textual examination of the Dune novels for their underlying themes, it is being written in the mindset of a historian. As such, broader historical contexts will be explored insofar as they better help to understand the Oriental themes within the novels. Fourthly, this essay will be operating on the underlying assumption that Science Fiction as a genre is equally worthy of cultural analysis, artistic critique, and historical significance as any other literary genre let alone any other form of art.[5] Finally, while this essay will be turning a critical lens onto the Dune novels and even onto Frank Herbert himself, in no way do I intend this essay to besmirch or belittle either the series or Frank Herbert. While this essay is critically examining both Dune and its creator, I do not wish to rob anyone of enjoyment of the series, let alone rob myself. Rather, what I hope to demonstrate is that the fictional worlds so many people love to lose themselves in are nevertheless produced in our real world. Their creators and their audiences equally base their beliefs on their lived experiences, those experiences themselves exist within a historical context and are culturally contingent. As Klein, Suvin & Lecorps note, “the real subject of a literary work (or group of works) is the situation of the social group the author belongs to.”[6]


[1] Alan W. Watts, The Wisdom of Insecurity: A Message for an Age of Anxiety, (New York: Vintage Books, 2011), p. 81.

[2] David M. Higgins, “Psychic Decolonization in 1960s Science Fiction,” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 40, No. 2, (July, 2013), p. 229. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5621/sciefictstud.40.2.0228; O’Reilly.

[3] Britt, p. 127.

[4] Rana Kabbani, Imperial Fictions: Europe’s Myths of Orient, (London: Saqi, 2008). p. 14.

[5] See Leon E. Stover, “Social Science Fiction,” CEA Critic, Vol. 37, No. 1, (Nov., 1974). pp. 21-24. https://www.jstor.org/stable/45258567; Diane Zigo & Michael T. Moore, “Science Fiction: Serious Reading, Critical Reading,” The English Journal, Vol. 94, No. 2, (Nov., 2004), pp. 85-90. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4128779

[6] Klein, Suvin, & Lecorps, p. 4. 

Wright argues that ‘when the story is a myth and the characters represent social types or principles in a structure of oppositions, then the narrative structure offers a model of social action by presenting identifiable social types and showing how they interact. The receivers of the myth learn how to act by recognizing their own situation in it and observing how it is resolved.’”

As quoted in Fjellman, p. 50.

Next
Next

Lisan al-Gaib