Lisan al-Gaib

“You cannot understand history unless you understand its flowings, its currents and the ways leaders move within such forces. A leader tries to perpetuate the conditions which demand his leadership. Thus, the leader requires the outsider. I caution you to examine my career with care. I am both leader and outsider. Do not make the mistake of assuming that I only created the Church which was the State. That was my function as leader and I had many historical models to use as pattern. For a clue to my role as outsider, look at the arts of my time. The arts are barbaric…. It stimulates the imagination. It makes people feel the lack of that which I have taken from them. What did I take from them? The right to participate in history.”[1] –Leto II of House Atreides, The God Emperor of Dune.

 

I listened to Duke Leto Atreides die for the first time when I was fifteen. His doctor betrayed Duke Leto as part of a political ploy by his family’s rivals, the Harkonnens. Yet, Dr. Yueh had replaced one of Leto’s teeth with a poison gas capsule. At the right moment, when Baron Vladimir Harkonnen believed he had reached the culmination of his revenge, what he believed to be the end of a centuries-long family vendetta, Duke Leto bit down on the fake tooth and spewed forth noxious chemicals into the air. The Baron’s Mentat-Assassin, Piter Devries, took the full force of the gas in the face, instantly breathing in the neurotoxins. The Baron was only saved because his personal shield was set to a low level, slowing the time it took for the gas to reach his person. Duke Leto knew not that his attempt had failed. Duke Leto knew not what had become of his friends and subjects: Thufir Hawat, Duncan Idaho, Gurney Halleck. Duke Leto did not know what had become of his loving concubine, Jessica, or what had happened to his son, Paul Atreides. Yet, Leto’s last thoughts recalled a memory of flying a kite with his son. The noble father, who by custom and by nature had been distant from his own son, spent his dying breaths thinking of his love for his child.[2]

The first time I listened to that audiobook of Dune, I was fifteen and I found myself transfixed by the story. A considerable aspect of what appealed to me about the story was that the main character, Paul Muad’dib Atreides—The Lisan al-Gaib—was also fifteen.[3] I felt an affinity with Paul, in many ways his struggle to internalize and challenge the expectations put upon him as well as the steps he takes to come to terms with himself is a quintessentially adolescent story. This is not to imply that Dune is immature, far from it, but that teenaged attempt to become one’s own person at a time where one is not quite old enough to make one’s own decisions, while at the same time being held responsible for decisions, spoke to me. That aspect of the story likely appealed to many readers over the last six decades and is arguably part of what keeps the Dune saga alive in contemporary science fiction. While that adolescent story is what hooked me and many other readers, the multifaceted layers of the series is what compelled me to listen to the book once or twice a year ever since. As I am writing this, I am thirty-one years old, and conservatively I could estimate that I have listened to the book roughly thirty times. Very likely, that number will only increase depending on how long I will live. I have loved Dune for half of my life. I waited in eager anticipation for the release of Denis Villeneuve’s adaptation of Dune in his two films, after I watched Dune: Part One in the theater, I cried driving home. Villeneuve had done a phenomenal job in bringing to the big screen a story that most people intuitively said was unfilmable.[4] Such is my love for the series that I am writing this essay.

The Dune series, written by Frank Herbert, has many layers to its narrative: on one hand it is a straightforward adventure story following a young male protagonist as he comes to manhood, in many ways it follows the Hero’s Journey to a tee. This is a significant reason why it was originally published in Analog magazine from 1963 to 1965.[5] On the other hand, the whole series is a deep critique of the hero archetype and points out the extreme dangers of thoughtlessly following false messiahs.[6] In this regard, Dune and its sequel Dune Messiah are together almost a parody of the Hero’s Journey.a Frank Herbert noted in 1969 that “the difference between a hero and an anti-hero is where you stop the story.”[7] The Dune series is not only a deep look at the ways in which humans impact and are impacted by their environment but it is also a deeply Liberal critique of political power and bureaucratic inefficiency as well as a dire warning of the impacts of technology on human freedom and choice.b The first novel, Dune, likewise heavily focuses on concepts of identity: what one perceives oneself to be, what others perceive one to be, and the tension that exists in between these two poles. The novels are likewise a meditation on human free will, human memory, and the human experience more generally. Furthermore, Dune, while set 20,000 years in the future, is deeply inspired by history and how cycles of civilization repeat themselves so long as human beings continue to exist.[8] “Dune is a massive saga,” noted Stephen M. Fjellman in what might be one of the greatest understatements ever written.[9] The series is incredibly dense in the best sense of the word.[10] One can read and re-read the novels and take away new lessons and observations each time.[11] According to Herbert’s thorough biographer, Tim O’Reilly, “Herbert believes that the primary function of fiction is to entertain….The best way to entertain is to provoke, to make people think.”[12] Science Fiction legend Arthur C. Clarke praised Dune, declaring: “I know of nothing comparable to it except Lord of the Rings.”[13]

It would not be inaccurate to describe Frank Herbert as an auteur genius, John L. Grigsby describes him as a “literary romanticist-philosopher.”[14] Willis E. McNelly noted that “The Dune series may be classified as science fiction’s true epic.”[15] Is it any wonder why Dune is considered to be one of (if not the) greatest science fiction novels ever written?[16] Is it any wonder why Dune not only won the Hugo award but also literally set the standard for the Nebula Award?[17] Is it any wonder why it is the most successful science fiction book series ever produced, the books being best-sellers four decades after the author’s death?[18] Brian Herbert, Frank Herbert’s son, declared (somewhat grandiosely) that “Dune ascended beyond the realm of science fiction, and has been called one of the greatest novels written by any author, and arguably the greatest novel of imagination ever conceived.”[19]Dune has remained relevant to American science fiction ever since its publication, spawning from it not only a series of six original novels but also continued by Frank Herbert’s son in an expanded universe of novels. Not only that, but the Dune series likewise birthed several critically acclaimed film and television adaptations, video games, songs, board games, graphic novels, and card games, among many other cultural artifacts. The influence of Dune is far-reaching, even those who have never read the books would likely recognize its themes and imagery in other works.c


[1] Frank Herbert, God Emperor of Dune, (New York: Ace Books, 1987), p. 382.

[2] Frank Herbert, Dune, 40th Anniversary Edition, (New York: Ace Books, 2005). pp. 158, 169, 179, 180.

[3] I am not alone in this. Kyle MacLachlan, the actor who played Paul in the David Lynch adaptation of Dune was an avid reader of Dune before he was cast in the role. He noted that “There were literally thousands of young men—if not more—reading the book and saying, ‘Yes, I am Paul.’”

As quoted in Britt, p. 150.

[4] Herbert, Dreamer of Dune, pp. 175-76.

[5] Upon its initial publication, the editor of Analog John W. Campbell Jr. wrote to Frank Herbert: “Congratulations! You are now the father of a 15-year-old superman! But I betcha you aren’t gonna like it….”

As quoted in Britt, p. 48.

[6] Stephen M. Fjellman, “Prescience and Power: ‘God Emperor of Dune’ and the Intellectuals,” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 13, No. 1, (Mar., 1986), pp. 54, 59. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4239722 ; Gerard Klein, D. Suvin & Leila Lecorps, “Discontent in American Science Fiction,” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 4, No. 1, (Mar., 1977), p. 11. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4239062; Julia List, “‘Call Me a Protestant’: Liberal Christianity, Individualism, and the Messiah in ‘Stranger in a Strange Land,’ ‘Dune,’ and ‘Lord of Light,’” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 36, No. 1, (Mar., 2009), p. 34. https://www.jstor.org/stable/25475206; Tim O’Reilly, Frank Herbert, (Frederick Ungar Publishing Co., Inc, 1981), Accessed May 21, 2024. https://www.oreilly.com/tim/herbert/index.csp

a It is for this reason that the editor of Analog magazine, John W. Campbell, Jr. refused to publish the second novel.

Britt, p. 93.; Walter E. Meyers, “Problems with Herbert,” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 10, No. 1, (Mar., 1983), p. 106. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4239533; O’Reilly.

[7] As quoted in Britt, p. 5.

b The question of a Butlerian Jihad, a Holy War to cleanse the universe of Thinking Machines, seems relevant in a world with ChatGPT.

See Schoni Song, “Preventing a Butlerian Jihad,” Journal of International Affairs, Vol. 72, No. 1, (Fall 2018/Winter 2019), p. 135. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26588349; See also Chris Pak, “Ecology and Environmental Awareness in 1960s-1960s Terraforming Stories,” p. 99, In Terraforming: Ecopolitical Transformations and Environmentalism in Science Fiction, by Chris Pak, (Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 2016). https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1gpcb56.7

[8] Peter Brigg, “Frank Herbert: On Getting Our Heads Together,” Mosaic: An Interdisciplinary Critical Journal, Vol. 13, No. 3/4, (Spring/Summer, 1980), p. 201. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24780272; Britt, p. 44.; Lorenzo DiTommaso, “History and Historical Effect in Frank Herbert’s ‘Dune,’” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 19, No. 3, (Nov., 1992), p. 311. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4240179; John L. Grigsby, “Asimov’s Foundation Trilogy and Herbert’s Dune Trilogy: A Vision Reversed,” Science Fiction Studies, Vol. 8, No. 2. (Jul., 1981). p. 153. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4239405.; O’Reilly.

[9] Fjellman, p. 51.

[10] Fjellman, p. 51; Brian Herbert, Dreamer of Dune, (New York: Tor, 2003), p. 185; O’Reilly; Ronny Parkerson, “Semantics, General Semantics, and Ecology in Frank Herbert’s Dune,” ETC: A Review of General Semantics, Vol. 67, No. 4, (Oct., 2010), p. 403. https://www.jstor.org/stable/42579070

[11] DiTommaso, p. 321; O’Reilly; Parkerson, p. 403.

[12] O’Reilly.

[13] Britt, p. 73.

[14] Grigsby, p. 154.  

[15] As quoted by William A. Senior, “‘Dune’ and the Modern World,” Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts, Vol. 17, No. 4, (Winter, 2007), p. 317. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44809216

[16] Grigsby, p. 149; Herbert, Dreamer of Dune, p. 171; Billie J. Hughes, “A Summer Reading List by Students for Students,” The English Journal, Vol. 70, No. 4, (Apr., 1981), pp. 52-53. https://www.jstor.org/stable/816636; Senior, p. 317.

[17] Britt, p. 5.; Grigsby, p. 149.

[18] Parkerson, p. 403.

[19] Herbert, Dreamer of Dune, p. 171.

c The most notable example of this would be Frank Herbert’s facetious claim to be part of the “We’re Too Big to Sue George Lucas Society.” Star Wars, likely the most prominent and mainstream example of science fiction, is replete with imagery and ideas that are inspired, or outright taken, from Dune.

Herbert, Dreamer of Dune, p. 289; Ryan Britt, The Spice Must Flow: The Story of Dune, from Cult Novels to Visionary Sci-Fi Movies, (New York: Plume, 2023), pp. 131-143.

Next
Next

Coyote